Why Counting Only Income Tax Payers — Millions Pay Taxes Through GST: Understanding The True Taxpayer Base In India

Why Counting Only Income Tax Payers — Millions Pay Taxes Through GST: Understanding The True Taxpayer Base In India

na

In India, the question of who qualifies as a taxpayer often creates confusion. Many people think that only those who pay income tax are taxpayers. However, this is a narrow view of the country’s tax system. In reality, every citizen who buys goods or services pays taxes, mostly in the form of indirect taxes such as the Goods and Services Tax (GST). Understanding this distinction is important to grasp how taxation works in India and why GST is so relevant today.

Income tax is a direct tax paid by individuals and businesses based on their earnings. According to recent government data, only about 7 to 8 crore people in India file income tax returns. This number is small compared to the total population of over 140 crore. This means that only a small percentage of Indians contribute directly to the government’s revenue through income tax. The reasons for this include many people living below the taxable income threshold, working in the informal sector, or not filing returns even when they should.

State-wise annual GST collection (2019-2025) (in Rs. Crore)

State/UT 2019-202020-212021-222022-232023-242024-25 (Till Nov)
Andaman & Nicobar Islands361255332373428287
Andhra Pradesh27,10826,16332,71040,23244,29830,056
Arunachal Pradesh5816517101,0231,308765
Assam10,42310,03012,00713,71015,60211,417
Bihar12,64011,63813,53416,54818,02112,760
Chandigarh1,9881,6511,9792,3652,7711,944
Chhattisgarh24,16024,41929,57131,96834,87424,119
Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman & Diu1,155 (Daman and Diu), 1,810 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)305 (Daman and Diu), 2,349 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)5 (Daman and Diu), 3,141 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)3 (Daman and Diu), 3,771 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)3 (Daman and Diu), 4,333 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)1 (Daman and Diu), 2,896 (Dadra and Nagar Haveli)
Delhi44,16136,56846,25355,84366,44552,980
Goa4,2803,2704,3645,5206,4754,592
Gujarat78,92374,34697,1551,14,2211,25,16890,838
Haryana59,56054,89068,14286,6681,02,91478,102
Himachal Pradesh7,9607,0558,0238,7789,9567,021
Jammu & Kashmir4,0103,6484,6925,2466,7044,861
Jharkhand22,84720,48227,85432,01934,73823,905
Karnataka83,40875,66095,9261,22,8221,45,2661,05,070
Kerala19,23417,34922,26427,37130,67721,822
Ladakh-114207333481345
Lakshadweep201318214514
Madhya Pradesh28,35427,00531,25536,23242,17429,438
Maharashtra1,85,9171,65,3082,17,9932,70,3463,20,1172,36,089
Manipur435392551615670490
Meghalaya1,5221,3371,7642,0762,2601,344
Mizoram296257316419500361
Nagaland317389420566711426
Odisha29,67729,84444,33549,44254,74839,612
Other Territory1,7531,3371,5902,6092,6151,645
Puducherry1,8711,6461,8242,3732,6361,893
Punjab15,23513,91318,40620,94924,06117,769
Rajasthan32,82131,79738,48045,45850,17435,436
Sikkim2,2482,2662,8113,1563,7072,696
Tamil Nadu74,43069,12185,4921,04,3771,21,32986,173
Telangana39,82036,34645,08151,83159,94241,065
Tripura6807327778841,053747
Uttar Pradesh65,28159,72173,86587,9701,01,69375,468
Uttarakhand14,72212,33913,68016,84519,23114,070
West Bengal43,38639,69447,89858,06062,61344,246

On the other hand, indirect taxes like GST are paid by almost everyone in the country. GST is included in the price of most goods and services, so whenever a person buys anything taxable, from food and clothing to mobile phones, they pay GST without even realizing it. Because of this, every consumer becomes a taxpayer in a broader sense. This greatly expands the tax base beyond those who file income tax returns.

GST was introduced in India in 2017 to simplify and unify various indirect taxes previously levied by central and state governments. It replaced a complex web of taxes like VAT, service tax, excise duty, and others with a single, nationwide tax system. This not only helped in reducing tax evasion but also made compliance easier for businesses. GST ensures that tax is collected at every stage of the supply chain and ultimately borne by the final consumer.

GST makes the tax system more inclusive, even if a person does not have taxable income or does not file income tax returns, they still contribute to government revenue by paying GST on their purchases. This means millions of people  outside the formal tax net are indirectly supporting public finances.

Direct Tax Collection

However, it is important to recognize that GST is a consumption tax and can be regressive in nature. This means that lower-income individuals may spend a higher percentage of their income on GST compared to wealthier citizens. To address this, essential goods such as basic food items are often exempt or taxed at lower rates. Still, the government needs to carefully balance tax rates and exemptions to ensure fairness.

The relevance of GST in India’s tax structure is clear. While direct taxes like income tax are important sources of revenue, indirect taxes, led by GST, contribute a major share to government finances. This reflects the reality that taxing consumption allows a much wider portion of the population to contribute, especially in a country with a large informal economy.

In conclusion, counting only income tax filers as taxpayers gives an incomplete picture of India’s tax system. Every citizen who consumes goods and services pays taxes through GST and other indirect levies. GST has redefined the concept of taxpayers in India, making it more inclusive and comprehensive. Understanding this helps in appreciating the true nature of tax contributions and the vital role GST plays in India’s economic growth and governance.

Disclaimer: The figures presented in these tables have been sourced from multiple publicly available government portals and reputable websites. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, discrepancies may exist due to variations in reporting and updates from different sources.

-->

About Us

The argument in favor of using filler text goes something like this: If you use arey real content in the Consulting Process anytime you reachtent.

Cart